I've stayed at the Whitfield and usually have their breakfast. It's generally o.k. - the massive pancake they serve is really tasty but just too big for a reasonable person to consume. It screams American in every way. I actually feel bad eating it knowing hunger issues abound, and that usually never happens to me, but it's definitely triggered by this ostentatious thing - I'd feel much better if they made a much smaller version, and out of principle restricted service of the thing to 2 or more diners.
Service is hipster and grungy but the hotel is trying really, really hard to make sure you're aware of all that, so try to appreciate the extra effort they're making, even if it is contrived.
I've honestly had better, but some of the better spots are jam packed for weekend breakfast, and while this fills up, no one is going to wait outside in the snow for 30 minutes to eat there...
Consider the 3-star rating very weak