This place is correct. A perfect 3.5. I had an old fashioned which was just okay (I'm not a big fan of crushed ice on my old fadhioneds) and a burger which was good.
The place feels like the evolution of the Squirrel Cage - you can't smoke in here, the music is fine and everyone seems friendly enough. The drinks aren't terribly expensive But the food isn't super cheap.
Like I said, I would totes give this place a 3.5 and if you've never been I highly recommend it! But it's not a 4.
That said, on the right night this place can be a 5 - great ambiance and lots of potential to have a great night here.