I'm a huge seafood person and loved this place! Whenever I travel to the US I always end up at The Boiling Crab (exact same concept as captain's boil) and I've always raved about how good it was and hoped that one day we would have one in Toronto and finally we do! Of course I had to try it and loved it! It's definitely comparable to the ones I've been to before and now I'm happy that there's one closer to home!
I went with my family and fiance (who are also big seafood eaters) for dinner on a Saturday. We wanted to do an early dinner around 5pm which I'm glad we did because it got really busy and the place isn't that big. There was a line up starting to form outside around 6pm. We pretty much ordered 1 pound of everything except for lobster and got the mild captain's boil flavour on everything! We also shared one order of their fish and chips which was ok...I've had better. Prices were what we expected so we weren't surprised but it is on the pricier side. And we had no issues with service.
If you love seafood and don't mind working for your food and getting messy then you'll like this place!