Here is another time when I wish for that extra half star...not quite a five but darn close.
It was a Friday night, my 24 yr old son and I were doing dinner so we decided to try this place we both have walked by but never had gone in.
The wait was 40 minutes (Friday night at 6:30...no surprise) so they took our name and downstairs to the lounge we went.
I loved the downstairs lounge. A bit dark, music a bit loud (they played Pearl Jam three times while we were down there according to my son). The bartender was busy but very quick and attentive. The beer draft selection was a great variety and did not disappoint. I really liked the atmosphere and will go back just to sit there.
The 40 minute wait turned into a 65 minute wait hence the drop of a half star ( plus the price is a little high). We each order a pizza with a whole bunch of stuff on it. These pizzas were definitely single serve but plenty for one person full of great beer. The taste of the pizza? It was Wicked Pissah( as my Boston tribe would say) which means awesome. Easily the best tasting pizza I have had in my six years in Wisconsin. It is a thicker pizza but has a very crisp crust with a slight garlic flavor. Plenty of sauce and toppings while an extra dollop of sauce on top well used on the edge crust pieces for dipping.
Oh for for the long wait the server gave us each a free beer of our choice.
I will be back. My son will be back. You should try.