Favorite thing at Milk Bar is hands down their corn cookie - sounds weird but don't knock it until you try it! The cook is soft and buttery, the perfect texture and right amount of sweet.
I like the cereal milk ice cream but a sample of it is plenty for me. The fruity pebbles flavor is uncanny - literally liquid cereal.
If you're looking to try the infamous Milk Bar and haven't made it to NYC, I love how accessible this location is. Also I've visited numerous times and there has never been a line!