First time at Graft was quite pleasant! I was quite happy with the quality of the food and the service. Our server, Sherman, was witty and goofy, which made our experience fun.
As other Yelpers have mentioned, the prices are quite high for the small amount of food that you actually receive. While I thought all the dishes I had were incredibly delicious -- and even said, "these are the best scallops I've ever had!" during dinner -- the bill at the end of dinner caused a little sticker shock. This is my reason for giving 4 stars instead of 5.
Even though I was really impressed with the service and food, I don't think I will go to Graft again for dinner. I think a visit to Graft is best suited for sharing a few apps and drinks, but not an entire dinner.