First time we ordered I got the thin crust and we thought it was just okay. We gave Mr. Jim's another go a few months ago with the original crust and garlic parmesan butter. Oh my! Seriously good stuff! My son is a fan of the double Pepperoni deluxe (I've added a pic) and my new favorite is the chicken premier. We probably order about once a week now. Check out the website for some good coupons.