Have only tried takeout so far but after hearing they were voted best pizza in Toronto and knowing it is just a few blocks from my house I had to try them out.
This area has a lot of good pizza places, and cellar door is no exception. Their pizza reminds me most of some of the pizza I had when I visited Naples, Italy.
I placed an order for takeout and they told me 10 minutes. Not even Domino's is that fast!
I had the Anna Maria ($16) and even though I had to drive it home in a box it was still fantastic. Can't wait to go back and eat at the restaurant as it looked very intimate and cozy, perfect for a date night.
If you like good Italian style pizza, definitely give them a try!