We recently visited Madison and went to Bluephies for dinner on the recommendation of our innkeeper. We were disappointed. The service was attentive, but the food was not very good. My pasta was OK. My wife's enchiladas were nearly inedible and hardly even resembled an enchilada.
The atmosphere was noisy and industrial. The bar drinks were meager pours and over-priced.. All the bottled wines are $30, but the list is over-represented with $7-$9 plonks.