Great food! The pizza was very very good. We happened onto the place because of a Groupon, and despite the hole-in-the-wall first impression and greasy smell the pizza was very good. This and Jimmy Joe's are our two favorites in town.
Unfortunately the Wing's were not near as good; they bordered on bad. That's ok, though. The pizza made up for it. We didn't try anything else.
Read some of the reviews about the bad service. We experienced only good service, a cashier/server who was willing to explain the menu and make recommendations. He was thoughtful as he came to our table, very polite. It was a little weird that he was wearing his muscle shirt and had his body building trophies on the counter, but he was nice nonetheless.
So our suggestion: Order the pizza, skip the wings.