Being a restauranteur in Indian Land has got to be the easiest job in America. That was my takeaway from dining at Mamas Pizza & Pasta. How is this place anywhere close to a 4 star cumulative average?
We went on a Friday night and the place was SRO so I figured we hit the jackpot. Like a fool, I ordered a sampler feast. I am here to tell you that this place serves frozen and microwaved food. The meatballs were waterlogged. The cheese on the lasagna looked like spackle. The spaghetti pasta was flavorless. And all of it is covered in a "marinara" sauce that tastes like it was store bought but they dumped a bunch of sugar into it to hide the taste.
Maybe the pizza here is great... I don't know. And I'm not trying to completely pan the place as it has its merits as a CiCi's type place where you can strap on the feedbag. You want to feed a bunch of kids? This is your place. However this should not be on anyone's lips as "authentic NY" anything.
I threw out most of my food by the way.