Probably 3.5 stars. We went for lunch and it was pretty good. The entrance is a cool little starting touch. It was very quiet in there, maybe 5-6 tables total. The service was good albeit not exceptional. Still, no complaints there.
We had the house and Caesar salads and both were good but nothing really special.
My wife had the chicken parm which she enjoyed.
My pasta was decent enough and you can tell they make it on the spot which is nice. I was disappointed with the sauce though. For all the hype I heard from the servers about it I found it to be rather boring. Too bad. They also didn't have any pasta salad available for a side dish which I found odd at a pasta place. On a positive note the meatballs themselves were delicious.
It's certainly not a bad place and we may try for dinner one night and hope for a little better.