A hidden gem!! Okay, not so hidden, but I've been walking past this place for years with zero desire to go in, but was looking for cannoli a few days ago and Sicilian Sidewalk Cafe came up in my search.
I went on a Sunday for lunch with my parents -- we ordered a couple different panini (veal, grilled veggie, and spicy sopressata) and they were all excellent and so cheap considering the quality and the neighborhood. Coffee was just okay. As for the cannoli, they are made fresh to order and definitely taste like it!! So many other tempting desserts and gelato flavors too....
Service-wise, staff was very friendly but this probably isn't the best place if you're in a really big rush (which I wasn't). Alternatively, I liked that we didn't feel pressured to rush out as soon as we finished our meal. I can def see myself returning here a lot, especially when the patio is open as the decor inside is pretty dated (which is probably why it took me so long to finally eat here -- I judge books by their covers a lot).