Since 4.5 stars isn't possible I'm going to round up and give them 5. I have been ordering pizza from there once or twice a month for about 4 years and the pizza is consistently excellent. It's just really well done NY style pizza with real cheese and toppings.
Be prepared to dab some grease which just means you're getting real cheese instead of processed which has much lower fat content as its full of emulsifiers. If you dig NY style you'll like this place.