A-OK sums this place up perfectly.
We went for restaurant week, and oddly enough ended up ordering a bunch of apps (not on the price fix menu)....so major fail on that end.
Reservation was for 6:15...girlfriend arrived at 6, I was there promptly at 6:15.....and we waited and waited and waited for our table. What is the point of a reservation I ask you. Now I'm not a fan of pushing people out, but not once as we were sitting at the bar did the hostess check in with us. We had to go up to her at around quarter to 7 and finally ask what was the story. This is why I did not give them 4 stars...the hostesses just couldn't be bothered. Very young and trendy, or what CLT calls trendy, so probably 'ovah' in a bigger market.
But I digress. Our waiter was also ho hum. It was loud in there and he had difficulty hearing us. Instead of perhaps bending down to get a little closer, he rather annoyed like told us to speak louder. Ok deafy mc deaferson...I'll scream my order next time. I'm sure the people at the table less than 6 inches from our table will really enjoy that.
So onto the food. It was good. The bacon pizza yummy, as was the pierogie. The salad was just meh as was the jerk chicken wraps.
Dessert was good according to my girlfriend - she got the smores trifle. I got the red velvet. I wasn't feeling the chocolate ganache but that's b/c I'm not a chocoholic, not b/c it wasn't good. The mussels were good but not very large.
So my closing tip to 5 Church...Get rid of the wanna be hipster staff and you'll have a true fan in this yelper.