I'd probably rate this higher except for the fact that the patio they have closed off for the winter basically doesn't have weather seal. We sat freezing for the entirety of the lunch. Seal up those gaps! I bet you could make back the cost of weather seal with a single day of heating that patio. Or just cut your losses and only seat inside. I would not eat here again if they tried to sit me outside.
The food itself was good. We had a few plates of calamari which were crispy and delicious. I don't really even like most sea food, but a lot of the fish taste was masked with the sauces and frying. I had "The Big Dyngus" sandwich for lunch. It's a good sausage with tasty chili on top. I didn't try any of the most recommended items for The South Side.