I'm not sure why there is such a hate on for this place on Yelp. The pie here is great!
At $5 a slice, this price is quite reasonable considering you're going to pay at least that much at a restaurant for any sort of dessert.
On my visit one late afternoon I was one of the only customers in the store. The employee working looked like she was getting things wound down for the day. She greeted me warmly and took my order and suggested I have a seat while she warmed and plated my slice.
She brought my order over a short time later. The crust was warm and flaky and there was a good amount of filling. I would put these guys among the top pie places in Toronto. Way better than Wanda's or any of the other more popular pie joints in the city.