I love Rigatony's! Every time I go I order OFF the menu and they never sniff at me sideways. Pasta is always perfectly cooked and the shrimp is always fresh.
The Mozzarella Pullapart was icky. Flat out. But then again, I don't like bleu cheese and I'm assuming Gorgonzola is similar (it is in color). Just not a fan.
The marinara is fresh and yummy (big chunks of tomato), and the apple bread pudding is TO DIE FOR!!!! Prices are pretty durn reasonable. Not a bad night out at all.
Never had a bad meal there. Took away one star for stinky cheese ... :P