It's Overrated! Plain and simple! The reason it's famous is that it offers aspects that most Phoenix restaurants lack: (1) It's not a chain (2) It has hip swanky northern California feel as it is next to a wine bar. It didn't hurt that Jerry Colangelo would publicly recommend this place for a date and soon it just became a hit. It was a trendier option to the usual bar food right before a Suns game. That's how it got famouse. People would park and dine here early before Diamondback and Suns games and then walk to the game afterwards. However, when the #1 ranking came out, it just drove this place through the roof. The food hasn't changed. Yes, they make great pizza but like another reviewer mentioned, i can think of at least 5 places in Phoenix that offer better pizza. Is it worth the wait...most certainly not. It's just annoying now because any out-of-town guest wants to dine here and taste the "best pizza in America" and they are always let down.