Wish I could rank the food and the service separately. The pizza was very good. MIL and I split a San Gennaro: thin crust, bright sauce, slightly spicy sausage, peppers, and caramelized onions. MIL didn't like it as much, but she doesn't do spicy, even a little bit. I would definitely have it again.
The best part of the experience, though, was the service. 5*! Both the young woman who made our pizza and the man (probably the owner?) were super nice and solicitous. He even gave us a free order of garlic knots and sauce for coming in - they were REALLY yummy! - and checked to make sure all was well. I'd return in a heartbeat because there are lots more choices on their varied menu I'd like to try - and to see their faces light up.