Despite the fact that I had the worst dish of all of us (fettucine carbonara- which was 3-3.5 star at best unless you had a some prosciutto in your bite, which then transformed it into a legit 4.5 star. *Note to chefs... more meat will make this sucker great), the other 4 dishes in our party were top-shelf.
1) Macaroni au gratin was phenomenal. A bit of subdued spice in the taste, a great layer of crunchy-melty cheese on top. We scraped the pan dry.
2) Friend's bacon cheeseburger was awesome. Got one bite and was convinced.
3) Wife's meatball sub.... drool. The bread was soft yet still had a bit of crunch, and the meatballs were fantastically seasoned to perfection.
4) Didn't try the other friend's lobster/shrimp angel hair pasta but he loved it, and said it was uber-generous with the seafood, unlike some places where you get only a few bits.
5) Chocolate toffee cake for dessert was good. I wanted caramel apple tart but was shouted down by two ravenous females in their neverending quest for chocolate.
*All of this is the late-night menu, starting after 10:30. Highly, highly recommended.