I'm surprised I'm only the second person to review this place...but let me tell you how cool it is!
The inside is just awesome...you'll feel like you've been taken back in time. And sometimes there's a dude playing the piano...every Sunday night I believe for a couple of hours?
Their selection is awesome - they have some super delicious ice cream and there's always a big line (but don't be scared away...it moves fast).
And they only accept cash...at least the last time I went they did so make sure to have some on you!
Spring/summer is coming...you should definitely check this place out :)