I tried this place with a friend after hearing/reading rave reviews and fiercely missing good sushi after a trip to Japan. Maybe I'm spoiled now but I found the majority of the sushi we ate to be quite good (not mind blowing) with the standouts being the amazing unagi (eel) and excellent beef tartare. Freshness was bang-on (though I admit, I've had even fresher at some local all-you-can-eats). Stunning plating and attentive staff.
I think the only major reason for the three stars is that I felt it was a bit overpriced. I'd rather pay a bit less on food and not bring my own wine.