I bought a couple of cake slices from here when I was traveling through Madison on business. To be honest, they were tasty but not something I'd buy on a regular basis for $5.00 per slice or more. The reason I'm giving 4 stars is because the place had a really great vibe, the staff was very nice, it is locally owned, and everything is baked fresh. I like to eat at and support these types of places. I just don't like paying $5.00 for a piece of cake unless it's out of this world. I'd still go there again and try something else though.