I was super excited when we got a Mellow Mushroom in the greater CLE area. I've ben to other locations in Raleigh and in Southern Ohio and I've never been disappointed.
The fam & the man decided to check it out on a Monday and avoid the crows at Angelo's. I was glad we did. This place was wide open for seating at 5:30 pm. Because I beat the fam / man, I had a beer at the bar. A wide selection of taps for the choosing and they had my favorite on tap, Rogue Dead Guy. MM is already a winner in my book just for that alone! They have a nice indoor / outdoor seating area along the bar which I think might be fun on a weekend.
Our server was great and was appropriately attentive and informative. We ordered 3 pies and mixed & matched so we could maximize our MM experience. They were all very good and I was pumped to have left-overs to take home!
I noted that the other reviews are mixed from great experiences to poor. While some of this may be due to the newness of the place, I think others are just perhaps unrealistic expectations. Look people, a good pie takes a while. If you want your 'za in 10 minutes, go to Pizza Hut. This stuff is hand-crafted, hand tossed, and has to be prepared appropriately. This stuff is mostly made-to-order and it takes time. If you're in a hurry hit up some fast-food people. Be happy you're not in the CHI where it takes 45 min for 1 pie.
I had a great experience, and while I don't think your decision on the MM should solely be based on mine, I would return and check this place out again. Quality product for reasonable prices. I was a happy camper.