I give Uncle Maddio's 5 Stars for concept and execution and an A-OK for the pizza for a solid 4 star total.
The decor is bright and cheerful and the whole assembly line fashion with which they run through the line, have you order and pay is impressive. Everyone I came in contact with through the process was friendly and helpful.
The pizza itself offers a great variety of toppings, sauces as well as three crust options. There are also plenty of gluten free choices. For me the toppings went from pepperoni (nothing special) to meatballs (good) to (carmelized onions (good to have the choice and they tasted good). The just meh parts were the tomato basil sauce which was much too sweet for my taste buds and the crust which is nice and thin and crispy but lacks that chew that great thin crust should have.
I also got a side Caesar Salad and while a little small for $2.99, it was good with homemade dressing. All in all, Uncle Maddio's is a decent new lunch option Uptown that should have some staying power.