This place is very nolstagic. It used to be two houses, then they combined them, then it became a furniture store, and still bears those marks, made apparent by the shag furniture still in the window up front. Nice touch. It's supposed to be haunted but our waitress informed us that she hasn't seen anything and says the building is settling. In the women's bathroom, you do feel like you're being watched, every step of the way. =)
We have sat in the trolley and in the booths. Bring a flashlight because it's way too dark. The menu resembles a newspaper. If you get overwhelmed by the menu, remember that you can always get spaghetti. We brought extra money just to get the Italian sodas in the Spaghetti Factory brand glasses. That way we got to keep the two glasses and have a souve. Authentic spumoni can be had here.