Wow, what a setup! Mitchell's Homemade Ice Cream is impressive as soon as you lay eyes on it. It's retro marquee draws you in and then the pristine look let's you know that this is no ordinary ice cream shop. The menu featured flavors, both traditional and funky. And the homemade aspect of this is clearly in its name. I went with the taster duo - half scoop of chocolate peanut butter cup and half scoop of one of their featured flavors, geauga maple walnut. Both were equally delicious. Mitchell's offers the essential toppings - whipped topping, sauces, and a few candy and fruit options. Once you get your ice cream, you can hang out in their large dining area or take a stroll down west 25th street. This place is going to be booming in the summer so make sure you take some time to check it out!
Update 9/14/14 - dogs are not allowed :( have to reduce my rating. I knew it was too good to be true! Building owners won't allow it.