First off, Burgatory has excellent service. Our waiter "Big Creepy" (according to the check) was very knowledge about menu. He guided us through the menu and was able to thoroughly answer questions I had about the menu. Moreover, he was friendly and attentive which made dining here a great experience.
Now for the heavenly shakes. I shared the Espresso Love and the Burnt Almond Torte; both were excellent! They were rich and creamy; I'd consider sharing one next time because of how filling they are.
Finally, the burgers. I decided to create my own burger and opted for an elk burger on herb focaccia with bayou Cajun dry rub, arugula, tomatoes, and red onions. I had it cooked to 'red' which is comparable to medium rare; I'd say that it was slightly more rare than most restaurants' medium rare which is great for those of us who enjoy juicy burgers!
If you're going shopping at the Waterworks, then plan on coming here for lunch.