I came to Il gatto nero during the taste of little italy festival. The menu they offered was limited, most of them are pizza-related.
My friend ordered the gnocchi and ravioli, and the portions are quite small for $15. I ordered the anchovy pizza, which comes with a nice thinly crusted pizza, with tomatoe sauce on top and all-too-salty anchovies. I was too busy chuggin down water to wash away the saltiness of the anchovies to even enjoy anything about the pizza.
This might be a good place to sit down and have coffee and wine, but definitely not a place to get a meal.