I've always had fond memories of Andre's since I first went many years ago to commemorate some occasion. I don't remember what we were celebrating anymore, but I remember having a really nice meal. So when my wife and I had an occasion to celebrate, I asked her if she'd like to go, and off we went.
It was... okay.
Maybe they were having an off night, or maybe it's because I've eaten at a lot more fine dining restaurants since I first went to Andre's, or maybe it's just because my tastes have changed. But it wasn't the great experience I remembered, and I left feeling kind of disappointed. It was good, but there wasn't anything memorable about it. I can't even remember what I had except there was duck involved.
I realize that part of the fault is my own; I let my expectations get too high and I guess I was bound to be let down. But in a city full of really amazing restaurants, I still feel like Andre's needs to do more to distinguish itself and not just rest on its (considerable) laurels.