This place is AMAZING! After moving out of NJ 8 years ago, we've had a hard time finding great bagels and had to settle for places like Brueggar's or Einstein's, which were average at best.
I keep getting their everything bagel, which is outstanding! I order it 'double-toasted' with their scallion cream cheese. I have also had their egg sandwich, and my husband loves their egg salad.
Not only does The Original Brooklyn Water Bagel Co have incredible tasting bagels, but their pastries are so fresh & delicious! My husband loves black & white cookies and this place is his new favorite. I'm not usually a fan of black & white cookies, but I LOVE these and end up eating half of his cookie! The muffins are great too - so tasty and fresh.
In addition to delicious food, the staff here is great! They are friendly, helpful and always make us feel welcomed! We've been there about 5 times in the past 2 weeks and will be back again soon!