3.5 stars sound like fair rating for Joey but my experience leans towards 3 stars.
Foods were good but for the price we expected better. Calamari appetizer had nothing special about it although it tasted good. Gyoza was greasy but then again it was yummy. I had blue cheese sirloin for entree, which was delicious. I think steaks here are pricier than the ones at Keg Steakhouse but I didn't think it was better than Keg's. My friend liked her pasta.
I was surprised to find some sushi on the menu. There were some Asian fusion foods, which I cannot comment on as I didn't order them. But if you like that stuff this place might be worth a try.
Service was so so but I have conflicted feelings about it. Our server was friendly and always smiling, but he was nowhere to be found to refill our water and drinks. I also had to walk up to the counter myself to get a new knife after dropping it on the floor. Then again, our server was so nice.