3.5 stars.
I went here for Tuesday Night Trivia. I have never been to a Trivia night, so can't compare to other places, but Cat n Fiddle was not bad at all.
From the outside, the place looks like a dive, but once you're inside, it is quite spacious and not grimey or divey. We had a huge platter of nachos to share and it was quite good! Lots of cheese and hot peppers, and three dipping condiments (salsa, sour cream and guac), all of which are usually the stuff I look for in quality nachos.
Trivia was hard though. Damn.