Im giving this place two stars because I love the first location at 20th St & Highland. That place was always great. This place was pretty bad.. at least on this visit.
We arrived to eat to see a packed parking lot. Many people were eating at Oregano's and we've always enjoyed NYPD. As we walked in, we were seating pretty quickly. Always a nice thing.
Nice waitress came over, took our drink orders and we also ordered an appetizer and a salad. Within 5min, both were out and we placed our pizza order.
In came more people to eat and we realized we were going to be waiting a long time. The table next to us who was seating long after us asked "I wonder what's taking so long?" That's when my girlfriend informed me that we've been sitting here for nearly an hour before our pizza showed up. I learned they were short staffed, but it would be nice to let your customers know that.
When the pizza finally came out, it was over cooked and wasnt great. Ive always raved about NYPD having the best pizza in town. Today (at least at this location), I was wrong. It was far from it.