Weber tires is awesome... Sure, it is a little rough around the edges (to say the least) but this no-frills shop has the best prices around.
I was just driving down VV tonight when my rear tire exploded... I was out in the middle of nowhere without a phone so i decided to limp it the mile and a half down the road to weber's at a whopping 15mph, tire flapping the whole way... when I got there it was exactly 5pm, the time they close... all the doors were locked but there just happened to be a man pulling a truck in the side bay door... I quickly ran up to him and asked "hey, can I use your guys phone?"... Once I got into the office I explained what had happened, and they quickly got to work, even though they were closed... They thew a used tire they had sitting in the back on my car and charged me 20$; 10 for the tire and 10 to mount and balance the used one as well as dispose of my shredded piece of rubber... they were done in under 10 minutes...
Now that is service!! They definitely saved my butt from being stranded in the dark on a cold winter night. Weber's is the only place I'll go to get my tires... I tried Broadway Tire in Sun Prairie once and has an absolutely horrible expirience...never again.
One thing to know about weber's is that they are always busy... Everyone knows they are the best so they get a lot of business... So you might have to wait a while if you don't get there early... I highly reccomend this place to anyone looking for new or used tires.