If Tony's were more consistent, I'd give it a 5 -- some days they have great NY style pizza and great staff. Other days / times, the pizza and staff are not nearly as good. If I stop in for a quick slice, I'm not sure which experience to expect, including the size of the slice (normally slices are large and 1 is a meal). The atmosphere is super casual - you order at the counter and pick up your food once it's ready. Single slices are available any time, or you can order a whole pie, pasta, sandwiches, etc. The only thing I wish were different is consistency.