So, you thought you'd try Heritage Tavern but you don't want to spend $40 a person? Go right around the corner to a Madison institution to The Old Fashioned and make sure you order their synonymous drink or one of the specialty versions they offer. The cheese curds are among the best in the city (I personally prefer the curds at Essenhaus but that's just me) and are not to be missed. Get a double order right off the bat!
You can't go wrong with an order of the Fish & Chips, the Old Fashioned Burger, or the really tasty Grilled Cheese sandwich. The mac & cheese is also a delicious coronary waiting to happen.
You don't go to the Old Fashioned to eat light - you go for the comfort food and the incredible beer selection. There's a great bar and lots of seating (a lot of corner booths) so this is a great spot for larger groups.
Use the Bartell Theatre next door as an excuse to get out and make the Old Fashioned your before, after, and if it's a crappy show- during, performance drinking and eating spot.