Coming from NYC I am very disappointed in this place. NOTE: when I first tried New York Bagel on Rancho in 2012 i thought they were about average for non NY or LA bagels. END NOTE
My office gets bagels every Friday for the staff. However, the last time we purchased bagels for the office the bagels from New York Bagel Deli and Gyros they were thin and small and had a different consistency than expected. That is why we stopped getting bagels from here for our weekly bagel day. It is clear that the person making the bagels does not know the way to properly make a NYC style bagel.
There are much better bagel options in town such as Bagel Cafe.