I'm giving this a hesitant 4. The burgers were fully satisfactory and my companion thought they were up there with the best burgers she's had. But, I've had Burger's Priest and Holy Chuck so the bar is set higher and the burgers here don't compare. They are better than the burgers at most restaurants, but they are pretty pricy. The milkshakes are good but the second time I got one there was ice in the milkshake (like the ice cream was icy) which kind of spoils it. I love me a good strawberry shake though!
PS the bacon is really good so get a burger with bacon on it!
PPS this place is usually not busy when I've been, so I hope they make it...