Spoiled by New Haven style pizza in Connecticut for many years, I could not eat any pizza when I first arrive in Madison.
Until I was introduced to Pizza Brutta.
I have been a fan since my first visit. Authentic and tasty Italian pizza, real oven, made to order, fast service, reasonable price, can't really think of anything to ask from this place. Everything is just perfect. Plus, I like it so much better than Chicago's deep dish style.
Prosciutto Arugula is my favorite, but I have tried at least 10 different pizzas on the menu. Never once I was let disappointed. If you are sharing, make sure you get both red and white pizzas so that you have good variation.