I recommend other places if you're looking for service and good steak. Last night I took my girlfriend there for her birthday, and we were unimpressed -- especially for a $300+ dinner for two. We went for the chateaubriand and by comparison, we think the same steak is far better at Barberians Steakhouse (we went there recently for a similar dinner). The steak at Barberians was more tender and not sinewy. What's worse was the service this evening at Hy's. While the restaurant wasn't super busy, we sat around waiting for service - dragging our dinner from 8:30 to almost 11. It was good to start, then the table staff service went downhill after the main course. If anything, I believe you're paying more for the setting. Go for that if that's your thing.