4.5 actually.
This is a cute little ice cream shop and grill. We were there strictly for the ice cream but someday will try their burgers and dogs. The ice cream was very tasty and they have a good selection of flavors. The prices are incredibly reasonable and the place has a retro feel to it. Simple and cute inside, a nice place to end up at the end of an evening out.
I feel like somehow I should write more about this nice little place, because I really do like it a lot. I will sum it up in a quite appropriate, simple, and monosyllabic word... YUM! Tony's, you've got a fan in me.