You know, I've gotta say I enjoyed this place. Cute little cozy spot to grab a bevvy or a decent pizza. I was there a few weeks ago with a friend who frequents this place quite often. We popped in to start our night on College Street and to grab a quick bite to eat and a tasty cocktail.
We scored a sweet spot by the window which was a quaint and cozy spot, and I think maybe the best in the house :) We both had a hankering for pizza, so we ordered the margherita with mushrooms as an add-on [the Ai Fungi pizza was a white pizza (without sauce)] and we both had a craving for a nice tomato-sauce pizza. Our server suggested that since the mushrooms were really saucy (they were marinated), that it would have been too wet with the tomato sauce and mushrooms which was why we opted for the margherita. I have to say the crust was very nicely done and the pizza itself was very tasty, and priced as a good pizza should be, at $10.50. Quite reasonable in my books.
Our server was also very nice and knowledgeable, so I would have to give Il Gatto Nero a positive on this one as well.
Great ambiance without being pretentious or overly done, and a busy spot for a Friday night out. I do recommend this spot, if even just for a drink and a quick appetizer to start out your evening.