Choosing a star rating was difficult because the restaurant is okay, but not great. It definitely isn't the worst option if you are staying at The New York New York, but it isn't among the best that Vegas has to offer.
We started with the beer n' cheese dip. It was gooey and yummy at first, but quickly became too rich. I had the shepard's pie which sounded very tasty from the description, but wasn't all that flavorful. It wasn't tempting to keep eating. My husband had the salmon and that came with a nice seasoning and sauce. His dish was pretty good.
There aren't a ton of Irish food options in Vegas so I'll probably be back at some point. It definitely wasn't a restaurant I'd write off and I'd probably come back to try some other food items.