Really enjoyed this place when I was in town. As the title suggests, this is a great place for small plates and not necessarily a full meal unless you plan to pair.
For starters I had the Fairylake Falls cocktail - I only drink when it tastes good and this absolutely passed the test. For dinner, I had a combination of perogies and mac and cheese. The perogies were great - simple, but tasty and surprisingly filling. The mac and cheese is topped with jalapeno Cheetos, which pack a little bit of heat but not specifically pricey.
But the initial draw to this place? The ice cream sandwich. Very simple concept but worth it. Only complaint is the cookies were a little burnt, which kind of ruined the experience a bit. Had the cookies been just right, the simple idea of adding the dip and the topping is spot on. A perfect treat to a "snack" meal.
Not to mention this little area of Newmarket is really charming - lots of neat little places to go nearby, walk around the lake, and the splash pad just down the street. And of course Snackmrkt itself is right on the "falls" so you can sit right by it, or inside with clear sight lines over to it. The location really is a knockout.