I have been waiting for months for this store to open up and didn't even know that they were 'famous' until after my first purchase.
Firstly, both times I've been in the store the line has been really confusing and I feel like I'm budding as there isn't much space and usually there is a line to the left of the door but you order to the right. A little bit of chaos
I bought a full size Carmella for my mom for her birthday and she said it was good, but I don't think she has tried any other ones and at this price point of $3 something for one.
The second time I went, it was actually a Sunday morning around 10 and I was disappointed that they didn't open until 12 which I think is really quite late. It's not very convenient to stop there to pick up cupcakes for a bridal or baby shower etc.
The third time I went I purchased the assorted set of minis and brought them to my girlfriends to taste test. We were all very disappointed and not worth the calories. For each one I tried I would compare them to a supermarket one and to the high end ones that sell for the same price. The mini dozen was $14. The chocolate icing was tasteless and an unexpected blah consistency. The lemon one was ok. I do not plan on ever going back and would rather detour to the downtown core (PG's) to pick up more quality ones that are worth the price.