Hmm I love bagels but I guess we didn't get the hype. Walked in randomly because it has a cute old charm to it (we didn't know anything of it's fame). Bagel was $1.25 and jumped to $3.70 with cream cheese... Is cream cheese a delicacy here? And they literally barely put any on there; half the bagel was dry. Maybe we got unlucky but it felt like a rip and the bagel was just ok but nothing great (strongly prefer NYC bagels).