I enjoy getting my haircut at Thorps. The atmosphere is pretty hipster/trendy--but you also see a lot of non-hipster clientele as well and no one is really out of place.
I'm not very picky about my stylist and usually am only getting a trim so it doesn't make a huge difference to me. I really like how when you book online you can see the experience and price for each stylist and then choose who you want to see. I find their prices to be very reasonable, you can get a good haircut including shampoo and style for about $30.
They offer water, soda, and PBR while you get your haircut which is a nice touch.