We come here pretty frequently (almost weekly), and have never been disappointed. Not sure what to say, other than every dish we've gotten has been excellent and high quality. The service is always friendly and top notch.
Great burgers (recommend their gouda); terrific pizza (highly recommend the peppadew). Never been disappointed in their sandwiches, including their hot roast beef and rachel. For apps, we really love the fried pickles, buff chicken dip, and all of their wings.
This place is a hidden gem. My only complaint is the lack of seating when they are busy!